This isn't about Bucky being able to handle it. It's about the fact that he's not a criminal, he's a man who will have had unconscionable things done to him beyond his choice or control to make him dangerous, and treating him otherwise isn't going to help him remember who he is, or make him any less dangerous.
He's gonna have so many people against him on all sides who're going to want to do exactly this to him or worse, but we've got to be better than that, Tony, for his sake.
It's also called trusting me to do the right thing. I'm not gonna lock you up, but that doesn't mean handing you back the weapon. You said it yourself, you either trust me or you don't.
I don't. I also said we'll figure something else out. That's what the trust is about — can you believe that or not?
[ he pauses, but not long enough for Tony to answer just yet. ]
Look, I can't give you a guarantee. But that's not our job. We're here to do the most good for the least damage. Not the most damage we can justify in the name of being safe. Guarantees are nuclear deterrents. They're making things we have no business making because we're afraid something less won't be enough.
You're not going to figure something else out, because when you need something like this figured out, you ask me, and I got nothing.
So, this is what I'm gonna do. I'm gonna build what I was gonna build anyway and if you don't need to use it, good for you. And if you do, then it's there— also, I spent the better part of a year being a nuclear deterrent, so...
no subject
no subject
no subject
no subject
no subject
no subject
no subject
no subject
[ it's very much the even-keeled, matter-of-fact tone of his commands. ]
no subject
no subject
no subject
no subject
no subject
It sucks that Barnes is having trouble with it, but locking up a dangerous criminal isn't wrong.
no subject
He's gonna have so many people against him on all sides who're going to want to do exactly this to him or worse, but we've got to be better than that, Tony, for his sake.
no subject
JARVIS, show Cap what we got on the Winter Soldier, skipping whatever you've managed to dig up from other universes.
[it's not that much info, but enough to get a very clear idea of just how dangerous the Winter Soldier is]
You want to keep him from doing harm and getting harmed, you're not gonna manage it with hugs.
no subject
You think this is anything I haven't already imagined? Tony, I'm not gonna let him hurt anyone. But I'm not gonna add to this, either.
no subject
The protocol currently in place requires denying you access to the suit and computers and notifying Captain Rogers, sir.
Hear that? It's called having sense.
no subject
It's also called trusting me to do the right thing. I'm not gonna lock you up, but that doesn't mean handing you back the weapon. You said it yourself, you either trust me or you don't.
no subject
You wouldn't need to lock me up because you can knock me out with a single punch. And you just said you don't have an alternative.
no subject
[ he pauses, but not long enough for Tony to answer just yet. ]
Look, I can't give you a guarantee. But that's not our job. We're here to do the most good for the least damage. Not the most damage we can justify in the name of being safe. Guarantees are nuclear deterrents. They're making things we have no business making because we're afraid something less won't be enough.
no subject
So, this is what I'm gonna do. I'm gonna build what I was gonna build anyway and if you don't need to use it, good for you. And if you do, then it's there— also, I spent the better part of a year being a nuclear deterrent, so...
no subject
no subject
I'll miss you.
no subject
[ and heads for the door. ]
no subject
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)